Back to All Articles
Legal Negligence
We Marketing
November 16, 2026
5 min read

Can You Claim Against Your Solicitor? What Three New High Court Rulings Show (November 2026)

Three new High Court rulings show when a claim against a solicitor succeeds and when it fails. What you need to prove, and your time limits.

Can You Claim Against Your Solicitor? What Three New High Court Rulings Show (November 2026)

Yes, you can claim against a solicitor whose mistake cost you money, but being unhappy with the outcome is not enough. Three High Court rulings handed down between 30 October and 11 November 2026 show where the line falls. One client was awarded £100,000 after a drafting error. Two other claims failed, one because the advice was found to be reasonable and one because the person bringing it did not follow the court’s own rules. Together they give a clear, current picture of what a professional negligence claim against a solicitor needs.

What did the High Court decide in the three rulings?

Three separate rulings, three different results:

Ruling What went wrong Result
High Court in Manchester, 6 November 2026, [2026] EWHC 2852 (Comm) A solicitor checking a legal charge (a document securing a debt against a property) deleted the wording that stated the amount secured and did not replace it. The law firm admitted the error. Client awarded £100,000 plus interest, against £180,000 claimed
High Court, King’s Bench Division, 30 October 2026, [2026] EWHC 2785 (KB) A business said its solicitors’ advice led it to settle an earlier claim for too little. Claim dismissed. The advice was reasonable and the client had suffered no loss
High Court, King’s Bench Division, 11 November 2026, [2026] EWHC 2893 (KB) A man said his former solicitors let the time limit pass on a medical negligence claim. He brought the case himself, without a lawyer. Claim struck out (ended by the court) for procedural failures, before the complaint was ever examined

What do you have to prove to claim against a solicitor?

You need to show three things: that the solicitor owed you a duty of care, that they fell below the standard of a reasonably competent solicitor, and that this caused you a loss. The three rulings show that the third point, the loss, is where most claims are won or lost.

In the Manchester ruling the mistake was admitted, so the argument was entirely about what it had cost. The judge did not ask whether the client would definitely have recovered its money. He valued the opportunity that had been lost, an approach lawyers call “loss of a chance”, and concluded that a settlement of about £100,000 was the most likely outcome if the document had been drafted correctly.

Can you claim because you settled for too little?

Only if the advice to settle was advice no reasonably competent solicitor would have given, and a better result was realistically available. Disappointment with a settlement is not negligence.

In the ruling of 30 October 2026, the judge found the solicitors and their barristers had formed a realistic view that the case had serious weaknesses. The settlement was reasonable, and a trial would probably have gone worse for the client. The judge also confirmed that a solicitor who still exercises their own judgment is entitled to rely on a properly instructed barrister unless the barrister’s advice is obviously wrong.

This matters for personal injury claims in particular. If your injury claim was settled quickly and for less than it was worth, a claim may be possible, but it will turn on what your solicitor knew, what they advised and what the medical evidence would have supported at the time.

What if your solicitor missed a deadline?

A missed time limit is one of the clearest forms of solicitor negligence, but the 11 November 2026 ruling is a warning about how the claim against the solicitor is then run. The man’s complaint was never tested. His claim was struck out because he could not show he had served his claim form (formally delivered it to the other side) and had no realistic plan for obtaining the expert medical evidence his case depended on.

The lesson is that a negligence claim against a solicitor has its own deadlines and evidence requirements. Our guide to what to do if your solicitor missed a deadline explains the time limits in detail.

What about a badly drafted will or other bad advice?

The Manchester ruling was about a commercial document, but the same principle applies to wills, property transfers and contracts: a drafting error that causes a loss can be claimed for. With wills there is an extra point. Since a House of Lords decision in 1995, a person who should have inherited can claim against a solicitor whose negligence over the will cost them that inheritance, even though they were never that solicitor’s client.

Be aware that will writing is not restricted to solicitors. Anyone can offer it, and an unregulated will writer may not carry the insurance that solicitors are required to hold.

Adviser and client reviewing a document file for a professional negligence claim

What do the three rulings have in common?

Each one turned on evidence, not on how badly the client felt let down. The claim that succeeded had a clear, documented error and a loss that could be valued. The two that failed lacked either proof of loss or the groundwork a court expects.

WE Solicitors has acted in professional negligence claims since 2001 and is a member of the Professional Negligence Lawyers Association. We review the file, test whether the loss can be proved, and tell you plainly whether a claim is worth pursuing.

How long do you have to claim?

Usually six years from the solicitor’s mistake, under sections 2 and 5 of the Limitation Act 1980. If you only found out later, section 14A can allow three years from the date you knew, or could reasonably have known, up to an overall limit of 15 years from the mistake (section 14B).

What is changing in 2027?

Two developments are worth watching:

  • Wills. In May 2025 the Law Commission recommended replacing the Wills Act 1837, including allowing electronic wills. The government has not yet brought forward a Bill. If the rules change, the standard expected of anyone preparing a will changes with them.
  • Protection when a law firm fails. In July 2026 the Solicitors Regulation Authority proposed higher contributions from solicitors to its Compensation Fund for 2026/27, building on its consumer protection review.

Frequently asked questions

Can I claim against a solicitor without a lawyer?

You can, but the 11 November 2026 ruling shows the risk. Procedural mistakes can end a claim before a judge ever considers what the solicitor did.

Does the solicitor have to admit the mistake?

No. An admission helps, as in the Manchester ruling, but most claims are proved from the solicitor’s file, letters and emails.

Do I need to prove I would have won my original case?

No. You need to show you lost a real and substantial chance of a better outcome. Compensation reflects the value of that chance.

What will it cost to find out?

Nothing. WE Solicitors offers a free initial consultation, and professional negligence claims are handled on a No Win, No Fee basis.

Speak to a professional negligence solicitor

If you think a solicitor’s mistake has cost you money, we can review what happened and explain your options in a free, no-obligation consultation. Call 0800 294 3065 or use our online contact form. You can also read more about claims against solicitors and other legal professionals.

Sources: High Court, [2026] EWHC 2852 (Comm), 6 November 2026 · High Court, [2026] EWHC 2893 (KB), 11 November 2026 · High Court, [2026] EWHC 2785 (KB), 30 October 2026 · Limitation Act 1980, section 2, section 5, section 14A and section 14B · Law Commission, Modernising Wills Law (May 2025) · Solicitors Regulation Authority, response on 2026/27 business plan and Compensation Fund (16 July 2026)

Need Expert Legal Advice?

If you or a loved one has suffered an injury due to someone else's negligence, don't wait to seek legal advice. Contact our specialist team today for a free, confidential consultation.

Related Articles & Resources

Explore our latest insights and legal news from our team of expert solicitors.

Emergency Contact

This line is for emergency assistance outside of our normal office hours.

Call 0800 294 3065