If a solicitor’s mistake causes your claim to be struck out (ended by the court), you may be able to claim compensation from the solicitor instead. A High Court case reported on 12 November 2026 shows how this works in practice. Claire Saywell, a British holidaymaker who was seriously injured by a falling palm tree in Sri Lanka in 2017, lost her injury claim against the travel company TUI because her lawyers, Slater and Gordon, did not deliver the court papers properly. She is now suing Slater and Gordon over a claim reported to be worth £4.5 million. The law firm has admitted the mistake, but it disputes that figure, disputes how strong her original claim was, and denies that it owes her compensation. Nothing has been decided yet.
What happened to the tourist hit by a falling palm tree?
Claire Saywell, from Sittingbourne in Kent and then aged 42, was sunbathing by the pool at a four-star resort hotel in western Sri Lanka when a mature coconut palm fell across her sun lounger and crushed her legs. The facts below come from press reports of the accident in April 2017 and of the High Court hearing in November 2026.
| Key fact | Detail |
|---|---|
| Date of the accident | 16 February 2017, at about 10.20am |
| What happened | A palm tree fell on her while she lay on a sun lounger, breaking both legs |
| Treatment | Emergency surgery in Colombo and 12 days in hospital before she was flown home. About ten operations since |
| Lasting effect | Continuing pain and disability. She has had to give up her career in insurance |
| Original claim | A personal injury claim against the travel company TUI UK Ltd |
| What went wrong | Her lawyers, Slater and Gordon, did not validly serve the claim form in time, and the claim was struck out |
| Claim now | A professional negligence claim against Slater and Gordon UK Ltd in the High Court |
| Position in November 2026 | Mistake admitted. Value and prospects disputed. Both sides will try to settle |
Why is Claire Saywell suing Slater and Gordon and not TUI?
Because her claim against TUI ended before any judge looked at the accident itself. She had instructed Slater and Gordon to bring the claim, and the law firm has admitted in the High Court that it failed to validly serve the claim form. Serving means formally delivering the court papers to the other side. She alleges the papers were sent to the wrong email address.
The rules on this are strict:
- Once a court issues a claim form in England and Wales, it must be served within four months (Civil Procedure Rules, rule 7.5).
- Email only counts if the other side has confirmed in writing, in advance, that it will accept service by email and has given the address to use (Practice Direction 6A, paragraph 4.1).
- On 21 February 2018 the Supreme Court refused, by three judges to two, to rescue a claim form that had been emailed to solicitors who had never agreed to accept it that way ([2018] UKSC 12).
A claim that fails at this stage usually cannot be started again. A personal injury claim must normally be brought within three years (Limitation Act 1980, section 11), and by the time a service problem comes to light that period has often passed.
Can you sue your solicitor if they miss a court deadline?
Yes. You need to show three things: that the solicitor owed you a duty of care, that they fell below the standard of a reasonably competent solicitor, and that this caused you a loss. Missing a deadline that ends your claim is one of the clearest examples of the second point.
The palm tree case shows that an admission is not the end of the matter. Slater and Gordon accepts it made the mistake. The whole dispute is now about the third point: what was the lost claim worth?
What is a “loss of a chance” claim, and how is compensation worked out?
You do not have to prove you would definitely have won your original case. You have to show that you lost a real and substantial chance of winning it or settling it. The court then puts a value on that chance, usually as a percentage of what the original claim was worth.
The Supreme Court confirmed this approach on 13 February 2019 ([2019] UKSC 5). You must prove what you yourself would have done, such as going ahead with an honest claim. What the other side or a judge would then have done is assessed as a chance, without re-running the whole trial.
To illustrate with round numbers: if a court decided a lost claim was worth £100,000 and had a 60% chance of success, compensation for the lost chance would be about £60,000.
That is why the two sides in the palm tree case are so far apart. Her barrister told the court that, with full evidence, her chance of success against TUI would have been more than 90%. Slater and Gordon’s barrister said it did not exceed 51%, and described the £4.5 million figure as highly contested. The judge managing the case called it a “loss of a chance claim” and said the question is her chance of a successful settlement or of success at trial.
Why does evidence about the tree still matter?
Because the court has to judge how the original claim would have gone. Slater and Gordon argues that the tree was brought down by a sudden gust of strong wind, a natural event with no human cause, so the hotel was not at fault and the original claim was weak.
On a package holiday, the UK tour operator is generally responsible for how its suppliers, including hotels, perform the holiday contract. That was the position under regulation 15 of the Package Travel Regulations 1992, which applied in 2017, and it remains so under the 2018 Regulations in force since 1 July 2018. Both sets of rules contain an exception for events that could not have been foreseen or avoided.
An expert on trees had examined the evidence in the original claim. His report, read out in court, said a spike and concrete had been driven into the base of the palm to secure a utility line, causing rot, and that these trees would not usually fall in high winds unless already rotten. Slater and Gordon objected, but the judge has given permission for that expert to give evidence in the claim against the lawyers.

What should you do if a solicitor’s mistake ended your claim?
Act early and keep everything. In practical terms:
- Ask for a copy of your file. Most claims against solicitors are proved from the file, letters and emails.
- Ask the solicitor, in writing, what went wrong. Solicitors must be honest and open with clients when things go wrong and explain fully and promptly what has happened (SRA Code of Conduct for Solicitors, paragraph 7.11).
- Keep the evidence from your original claim. Photographs, medical records, witness details and expert reports all help to show what your claim was worth.
- Get independent advice. The solicitor who made the mistake cannot advise you on a claim against themselves.
Law firms regulated by the Solicitors Regulation Authority must carry professional indemnity insurance (SRA Indemnity Insurance Rules), so a successful claim is normally paid by an insurer.
WE Solicitors has acted in professional negligence claims since 2001 and is a member of the Professional Negligence Lawyers Association. We review the file, test what the lost claim was realistically worth, and tell you plainly whether a claim is worth pursuing. Our guide to what to do if your solicitor missed a deadline covers the first steps in more detail.
How long do you have to claim against a solicitor?
Usually six years from the solicitor’s mistake. The main time limits are:
| Step | Time limit | Source |
|---|---|---|
| Start a personal injury claim | 3 years from the injury, or from when you knew about it | Limitation Act 1980, section 11 |
| Serve a claim form once the court has issued it | 4 months (in England and Wales) | Civil Procedure Rules, rule 7.5 |
| Claim against a solicitor for negligence | 6 years from the mistake | Limitation Act 1980, sections 2 and 5 |
| Claim against a solicitor if you found out later | 3 years from when you knew, or could reasonably have known, up to 15 years from the mistake | Limitation Act 1980, sections 14A and 14B |
| Complain to the Legal Ombudsman | 1 year from the problem, or from when you found out about it, and within 6 months of the firm’s final response | Legal Ombudsman |
The six years can start running earlier than people expect, so it is safer not to wait for the outcome of a complaint before taking advice.
Frequently asked questions
Did Claire Saywell, the tourist hit by the palm tree, receive £4.5 million?
No. As of 12 November 2026 nothing has been awarded. The £4.5 million figure is disputed by Slater and Gordon, and both sides have said they will try to settle through alternative dispute resolution, which means negotiation or mediation without a trial.
My solicitor admitted the mistake. Does that mean I will be paid?
Not automatically. As the palm tree case shows, a law firm can admit the error and still argue that the claim you lost was weak or worth less than you say.
Can a claim form be served by email?
Only if the other side has agreed in writing beforehand and given an email address for service. Without that agreement, an emailed claim form may not count as served at all.
Should I complain to the Legal Ombudsman or make a negligence claim?
The Legal Ombudsman is free and deals with poor service, but there is a limit on what it can award. A substantial financial loss, such as the value of a lost injury claim, usually calls for a professional negligence claim.
Can I claim in the UK for an accident at a hotel abroad?
Often, yes, if it was a package holiday. The claim is generally made against the UK tour operator in the courts here. Different, sometimes shorter, time limits can apply to accidents abroad.
What will it cost to find out where I stand?
Nothing. WE Solicitors offers a free initial consultation, and professional negligence claims are handled on a No Win, No Fee basis.
Speak to a professional negligence solicitor
If a solicitor’s mistake has ended your claim or left you with less than you should have received, we can review what happened and explain your options in a free, no-obligation consultation. Call 0800 294 3065 or use our online contact form. You can also read more about claims against solicitors and other legal professionals.
Sources: Daily Mail (via MSN), report of a High Court preliminary hearing, 12 November 2026 · KentOnline, 26 April 2017 · Irish Examiner, 26 April 2017 · Daily Mirror (Sri Lanka), 27 April 2017 · Civil Procedure Rules, rule 7.5 and Practice Direction 6A, paragraph 4.1 · Supreme Court, [2018] UKSC 12, 21 February 2018 · Supreme Court, [2019] UKSC 5, 13 February 2019 · Limitation Act 1980, section 2, section 5, section 11, section 14A and section 14B · Package Travel, Package Holidays and Package Tours Regulations 1992, regulation 15 · Package Travel and Linked Travel Arrangements Regulations 2018 · SRA Code of Conduct for Solicitors, paragraph 7.11 · SRA Indemnity Insurance Rules · Legal Ombudsman, consumer FAQs